"Company Man" might just be the best episode of The Company You Keep yet. Wonderfully directed by James Takata, with a great script by Morgan Faust & JD Shields, the episode makes what could be a complicated plot seem simple and coherent. It mixes the narrative with emotional moments involving nearly all of its ensemble, while seamlessly bringing Daphne in to complicate Emma and Charlie’s romance, and even explores themes of sexism, hiding the truth to protect family, and the blurred lines between good and evil. All in all, "Company Man" propels The Company You Keep in an exciting new direction, while setting the perfect template for future episodes, too.
- Gregory James Wakeman, WhatToWatch.com